Brio Italian Grille

Buono’s Pizza in Gilbert offers authentic NY-style pies with a crispy crust and flavorful sauce. The cozy, NY-decor atmosphere invites dine-in or takeout, with seat-yourself service and friendly staff. Highlights include margherita and white pizzas, boneless wings with honey BBQ and buffalo sauces, and lasagna praised as the best AZ has to offer since moving here. The lunch special features two slices and a soda, and outdoor seating with beer options adds to the welcoming experience.

Fire & Brimstone Pizza Restaurant in Gilbert delivers wood-fired, brick-oven pizzas in a lively complex of shops and a brewery. Outdoor seating with misters keeps guests comfortable, while counter service delivers pizzas to tables. Fans praise Cesar salad and butternut squash soup, plus pizzas like carnivore, prosciutto and fig, and buffalo chicken, all crafted from high-quality ingredients.

North Italia, located at 1950 E Williams Field Rd #102 in Gilbert, AZ, blends Italian classics with a lively bar scene. Praised dishes include Eggplant Parmesan, Crushed Meatball Ragu, and a limited-time jalapeño popper pizza, plus tiramisu. The bar offers thoughtful recommendations (Old Fashioned) and a welcoming staff, with occasional wait times noted by guests.

Crust Simply Italian Gilbert delivers a welcoming Italian dining experience in Gilbert’s Cooley Station. Guests consistently praise friendly, attentive staff, timely service, and spot-on recommendations. The menu features favorites like chicken Francese, garlic knots, meatballs, salmon, stromboli, short rib pasta, and linguine with clams. Reservations are recommended during peak times; a Mother's Day note mentioned a 'Mom's eat free' promotion.

Grimaldi's Pizzeria in Gilbert, AZ serves wood-fired brick-oven pizza with a real New York–style feel. Reviews highlight authentic coal-fired flavor, a simple, clean menu, and friendly staff. Guests enjoy quick salads and garlic knots, bar seating, and a lively dining vibe before the main pies. Located at 2168 E Williams Field Rd #102.

Oregano's is a lively Italian restaurant in Gilbert, AZ, offering generous portions in a cozy, vibrant setting. Guests praise attentive service—especially Nick—and flavorful pastas like Diablo Shrimp. Reviews highlight friendly hosts, timely service, and a welcoming atmosphere in the heart of Gilbert. Some diners note occasional extra charges for sauces or side swaps, but meals consistently earn high marks and repeat visits.