C-
Carmine's - Time Square
Carmine's - Time Square: Generous, family-style Italian meals in the heart of NYC.
4.8
Italian
$$
Est. 1990
Carmine's - Time Square: Generous, family-style Italian meals in the heart of NYC.
Carmine's - Time Square is a bustling Italian restaurant at 200 W 44th St, New York, offering generous, family-style dishes. Critics praise huge portions—calamari and chicken parm—and plentiful bread baskets, plus Titanic ice cream dessert. The lively atmosphere pairs attentive service (Kiara highlighted) with shareable meals, making it ideal for groups, celebrations, and to-go leftovers.
No photos available
Enjoy generous portions of classic Italian dishes like pasta, chicken parmigiana, and calamari, perfect for sharing with groups.
Bring Carmine's authentic Italian flavors to your events with professional catering for parties, corporate gatherings, and celebrations.
Order your favorite Italian meals for delivery, offering the same hearty portions and quality as in-restaurant dining.
Celebrate birthdays, anniversaries, and other milestones with a festive atmosphere and customizable dessert options like the Titanic sundae.
Fully accessible entrance, seating, and elevator for a comfortable dining experience for all guests.
Overall rating
Katherine S
Carmine’s Italian Restaurant was absolutely amazing! From start to finish, the experience was worth every minute. Our waitress, Kiara, was phenomenal. She was so kind, attentive, and genuinely made us feel taken care of the entire time. The food came out perfectly cooked and full of flavor, with very generous family-style portions. Seriously…huge servings. They even packed our to-go boxes neatly and thoughtfully which was such a nice touch. We didn’t have a reservation and waited about 45 minutes, but it was beyond worth it. The atmosphere, service and food all delivered. We’d gladly wait again. Highly recommend if you’re in NYC and want a memorable, comforting Italian meal.
KRISTI JOHNSON
George and Felix were amazing from the start. Best recommendations from the Caesar salad, house bread (the red bread), to the country style pasta-we added the chicken, and chicken parm…..oh and hats off to our home state Oklahoma we had a bottle of Fat Ninte(boys from Oklahoma) ….the best! This was split between 4 and we still left lots of food and wanted dessert but we were stuffed! Thank you George and Felix for making us feel like it was a family dinner at the bar. We had reservations but lived then so we gave up the table;)
Christy Dowless
Carmine’s did not disappoint! The food was amazing and such huge portions for the price. You will definitely want to go hungry and be prepared to share or have a ton of doggie bags. The food was delicious and have the authentic homemade Italian food. I would definitely recommend and will be back when in the area.
Kyara Melo
it's a big restaurant. They have wheelchair accessible entrance and seating, they have a elevator, they have a coat check in for coats & strollers. This restaurant is family-friendly you can come alone or for a date or even with your kids. The wait is crazy this restaurant is very busy and packed, even with a reservation you have to wait for a table. you have to do a reservation they never have tables available it be so packed. The waiters are nice and friendly they so be so busy but they make sure they pay attention to you and they make sure you good everytime. The drinks was wack taste like juice, the food was amazing it taste very good the steak is expensive but is worth it has great taste one of the best steaks I ever tasted with great flavor and seasoning. The dishes are huge so you can share with 3 people or even 4. I came for my nephew's birthday he loved it we got him the sundae which was amazing the whole table got some. This restaurant is a great Italian restaurant i would come back. the drinks need to be better.
gordon leung
Great food. Huge portions. Best if you are in a large group since each entree feed 3 people. We loved the calamari and chicken parmigiana. Very generous bread baskets. The titanic ice cream dessert was delicious. It’s a little loud so you have to speak loudly for conversation.
Claim Carmine's - Time Square to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
