Cento

Osteria Pizzeria in Columbus's Old Town serves pizza and Italian dishes with a welcoming neighborhood vibe. Guests praise attentive staff, quick service, and bar seating, perfect for watching a game. Signature items include cauliflower crust pizza, Numero Uno pizza, pollo pizza, peppers in oil, and Caesar salad, plus peach-season specials and peach cobbler for dessert. Dine-in or takeout is available.

Martini Modern Italian in Columbus delivers refined Italian dining on the 3rd floor of 445 N High St. The space blends a sleek modern edge with warm, comfortable seating and is consistently praised for attentive service. Guests highlight dishes like truffle garlic bread, chicken carbonara, salmon, and lasagna, plus craft cocktails. Valet service and a history dating back to 1996 are noted by guests.

Due Amici is an Italian restaurant in Columbus offering classics like veal meatballs, chicken parmesan, bruschetta, and filet mignon. Guests praise flavorful dishes and attentive service, with a lively cocktail lounge and a popular happy hour six days a week. Located at 67 E Gay St, it’s a trusted staple in the local dining scene.

Speck Italian Eatery in Columbus, OH, located at 89 N High St, delivers contemporary Italian dining with a warm, intimate ambiance. Guests laud attentive service and a well-curated menu—bone marrow pasta, mussels, scallops, focaccia, burrata, and tortellini in brodo—plus a chef’s counter and bar seating. Reservations include time limits; valet or corner parking is available, and a 3% wellness surcharge applies.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North serves authentic NY-style thin-crust pizza at 608 N High St, Columbus. Customers praise great flavor, generous slices, and affordable deals in a warm, welcoming space with friendly staff. A rear bar hosts events and live entertainment, and lunch specials alongside ample seating complete the cozy dining experience.

Marcella's is a fine dining Italian restaurant in Columbus, Ohio, located at 615 N High St. The menu shines with roasted garlic cheese bread, fettuccine and meatball, and chicken parmesan. Guests praise attentive service from Asher and Sam, and standout items like Caesar salad with white anchovies and carbonara. Happy hour offers half-price pizzas, and reservations are recommended.