Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North

D

D.N.M.via Google

about 2 months ago

Great pizza and fantastic deals! Goodfellas Pizzeria in Columbus is an excellent spot for a delicious pizza. The quality is great, the prices are very affordable with super deals, and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming. The staff is extremely friendly and makes you feel right at home. Highly recommended if you’re looking for a good pizza in a cozy environment! 😊

T

T Hvia Google

3 months ago

11/10/2025. I had lunch because of the 50% off a 12” pizza on Monday special. A very clean, organized restaurant with an old school NY vibe and a very nice bar at the rear of the restaurant. There is a public courtyard right outside the restaurant where you can enjoy your food on a nice day. No restaurant seating outside but there’s big concrete benches and knee wall ledges the city created for places to sit. I ordered the special with pepperoni - final cost below $10. You’ll receive a thin, soft crust, NY style pizza cut in pie wedges. It’s a very good pie. The pepperoni are large versus the old school grease cup pepperonis but they are still decent. For the cost and quality of the food this deal is hard to beat.

V

Vincent Lamvia Google

3 months ago

This new Goodfellas pizza shop was amazing. Their pizza was freshly baked and authentic with thin crust. My veggie pizza tasted great with their tomato dipping sauce. Service was amazing and WiFi was fast. There were many comfy seats, screens, and even a secret bar. Lunch combos were cheap and great.

M

Miguel Hernandezvia Google

3 months ago

09/20/2025 - First time visiting Goodfellas Pizzeria - Short North with family and friends for lunch and we dined in. I ordered their special that includes a slice, a breadstick, and a drink. The slice was generous, and reminiscent of east coast flavor, and delicious. The wall decor homages characters from early 20th century with modern technology providing entertainment. The names of their specialty pizzas also tribute characters from then who have passed and some that are still with us. At the back of the restaurant there is a nice size bar that hosts events, private parties, and live entertainment. You may choose booth seating to bar seating. Friendly staff. Paid street parking out front, across the street, or paid parking garages also nearby. Great prices for delicious pizza! Enjoy.

N

Neil Fanchervia Google

3 months ago

First, the pizza was outstanding. Nice crust and toppings and sauce was ideal: not too much and nice sweet hint of anise. Warm roasted garlic was such a nice accent to the sweet anise. Super friendly staff, prompt service. Front dining area bright and clean and a dark, chill bar in the back—best of both worlds!