Chicago Style Pizza

Name: Chicago Style Pizza
Address: 534 Upper Sherman Avenue, Hamilton, ON, L8V 3M1, CA
Telephone: (905) 575-8800
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.2

Chicago Style Pizza: Deep-dish flavor with a warm Hamilton welcome.

4.2(5 reviews)

pizza

Directions Call Website

About

Chicago Style Pizza serves Chicago-style deep-dish pizza and Italian favorites at 534 Upper Sherman Ave, Hamilton, ON. The inviting atmosphere pairs with attentive service and generous, cheese-rich dishes like the deep-dish pizza and crispy fried ravioli. Reviews highlight great value and family-friendly portions, though one guest found a stuffed-pizza order less satisfying.

Photos

1 / 1

Location

534 Upper Sherman Ave, Hamilton, ON L8V 3M1, Canada

Get directions

Information

534 Upper Sherman Avenue

Hamilton, ON, L8V 3M1

(905) 575-8800 www.chicagostylepizza.ca/

Is this your business?

Claim Chicago Style Pizza to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.

Services

Deep-Dish Pizza

Authentic Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas loaded with rich cheese and flavorful toppings, baked fresh to order.

Italian Classics

Hearty dishes like lasagna, fried ravioli, and garlic bread, made with traditional recipes and high-quality ingredients.

Dine-In Experience

Cozy restaurant seating with warm, attentive service, perfect for family meals or casual gatherings.

Takeout & Pickup

Convenient ordering by phone or online, with timely preparation for easy pickup of hot, fresh meals.

Catering & Large Orders

Ideal for events or group meals, offering generous portions that reheat well for leftovers.

4.20 · 5 reviews

Overall rating

Christine Larue

via Google

· 9 months ago

The only time I had eaten deep-dish pizza before was in Chicago. I’m so glad I found this place — even though it’s not close to home, the drive was absolutely worth it. The cheese on the pizza was incredibly stretchy, the flavor was excellent, and everything was well balanced. The cheese bread was also very good. The service was excellent, even though the restaurant was full. Being served with a smile is rare these days and was truly appreciated. Overall, it had been a long time since I’d had such a good pizza. Highly recommended.

Vlado

via Google

· 9 months ago

Picked up a “stuffed” Chicago style pizza. Looked and smelled like the genuine thing. It ended up tasting like a hot pocket. It tasted like it was frozen and not freshly made. Chicago style pizzas are not, barely, an inch thick. Extremely disappointed. The service at the front desk was great, but would not order pizza from here again.

Caydie Maerz

via Google

· 10 months ago

Absolutely loved our experience at Chicago Style Pizza. The environment was warm and welcoming with a great vibe from the moment we walked in. Our waitress was the sweetest and very attentive which made the experience even better. The fried ravioli was perfectly crispy and delicious. The deep dish pizza was loaded with the most amazing cheese rich flavorful and incredibly satisfying. Totally worth every dollar spent. Beautiful food beautiful flavours and beautiful vibes all around. Highly recommend 🍕✨

Matthew Reid

via Google

· 10 months ago

For the past year since moving to Hamilton my wife and I have been trying all the great pizza spots and this is for sure top two! It’s a bit out of our way so we don’t go often because usually pizza is chosen for a convenient quick meal, but if we want to have a really good pizza this is the top of the list! The service has always been great and the price is reasonable especially given how good it is. I will always recommend this place to people looking for something new. It’s also super filling and we always have leftovers that reheat really well!

Jim T

via Google

· 11 months ago

Ordered from here actually a couple times this week. Had a craving for lasagna and a friend recommended this establishment. I placed an order over the phone and it was ready for pickup 45mins later right on time. The 2nd order I placed online through their website and paid online 2 hours before they opened and my meal was hot and ready for pickup shortly after they opened. I got both times their Large lasagna which comes pretty good in size I recommended getting extra cheese. The lasagna was very tasty perfect and the whole family was happy, content, and full. The garlic bread and cheese I must admit was probably the best I've ever had, nice portion size and very generous with the cheese. I definitely recommend this establishment if lasagna is your favorite dish! I wanna try their deep dish pizza next well if the family don't want lasagna again haha.

More businesses like this

View details →

pizza

Hamilton, ON

Maipai

Maipai is a Detroit-style pizza spot in Hamilton, Ontario, located at 631 Barton St E. It’s known for bold, flavorful pies—from pickle pizza to the 'do you wanna' with fig jam, ricotta and basil. The tiki-inspired decor and lively atmosphere make it a memorable visit, with reservations often recommended. The menu offers halal/vegan substitutes and creative cocktails such as Cuban libre and cocojito.

View details →

pizza

Hamilton, ON

Shorty's Pizza

Shorty's Pizza in Hamilton serves huge, thin, crispy pies with a signature sesame-crusted crust. The retro, Brooklyn-inspired space features an open kitchen and a back patio, creating a welcoming vibe. The menu offers large slices or whole pies, plus standout banana pudding, and friendly, attentive staff.

View details →

pizza

Hamilton, ON

Cowabunga+

Cowabunga+ in Hamilton serves standout NY-style pizza with a crispy, flavorful crust and fresh toppings. Guests praise juicy wings, Parmesan fries, and generous portions, along with friendly, efficient service for dine-in or takeout. Reviews highlight award-winning pizza and a welcoming atmosphere, making Cowabunga+ a go-to spot for pizza lovers exploring Hamilton.

View details →

pizza

Hamilton, ON

Pizza Fiamma Hamilton

Pizza Fiamma Hamilton offers Neapolitan-style, wood-fired pizzas with creative Indian-inspired toppings in Hamilton. Diners praise Punjabi-style pizzas and fusion options like Tandoori Chicken and Tandoori Paneer pizzas, with bold, well-balanced flavors. Reviews also mention items such as momos and noodles spring rolls. Friendly service, including staff member Gagan, receives praise. Some reviews note higher prices and opportunities to improve ambiance and organization.

Directions Call