City Nail Bar: Precision nails and attentive service in a beautiful Indy space
City Nail Bar is a nail and beauty salon at 71 N New Jersey St, Indianapolis, IN 46204. Customers praise Tiffany for detailed cuticle care, Samara and Jimmy for precise pedicures and lasting nail health, and Kiara for a warm, welcoming experience. Some reviewers describe it as one of the best nail salons in Indy, though one client notes builder gel issues. The space is frequently described as beautiful and inviting.
71 N New Jersey St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA
Claim City Nail Bar to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
Basic to gel manicures with cuticle care and nail shaping for healthy, polished nails.
Classic pedicures with foot massage and exfoliation for relaxation and rejuvenation.
Builder gel and other enhancements for durable, stylish nails with attention to nail health.
Custom designs and intricate nail art to match your style and inspiration.
Additional beauty treatments in a serene setting for a full pampering experience.
Overall rating
Makayla Yeary
First time here and I will definitely be returning! Got a basic manicure with gel and was serviced by Tiffany! Her attention to detail is incredible. She took her time making sure my cuticles were taken care of. Beautiful space and amazing service!
Ryan Reed
When you need your caveman feet to be brought back to the 21st Century and you’re in Indy, this is the place for you. Upon entry I was offered a beverage. Kiara took care of me and was very polite and welcoming. I got the classic pedi and the foot massage was perfect. Thanks to the good folks of city Nail bar I have human feet again. I plan to come back on my next layover. Definitely recommend this spot. Ask for Kiara:)
MC Dobie
Samara (Sam) is the absolute best. Her attention to detail and truly looking to better my foot and my nail is obvious. This was my second pedicure with her and my first manicure and I won’t be planning to use anyone else but her.
Jessica Kaplan
Hands down the best nail salon I have ever been to in Indy! JIMMY IS BEYOND TALENTED and goes above and beyond every time. His attention to detail is amazing and he has also made sure that my natural nails stay long and healthy like they looked before I started seeing him. I was worried my nails would break or not grow as fast but I’ve seen no damage at all from the builder gel and they’re still strong as ever! I found my inspo from Pinterest and as you can see, he did a fantastic job as usual and my nails essentially look exactly like the nails in the inspo photos! HIGHLY recommend going to Jimmy and I’m sure the rest of the manicurists there are excellent as well. I live and work right across the street and multiple coworkers of mine now get their nails done as well and have nothing but amazing things to say. I look forward to my next appointment and highly suggest you make this your new go to salon 😊💅
Jasmine Jackson
This is such a convenient venue and aesthetically pleasing. I’ve visited a few times and won’t be going back. The builder gel broke within one day and is not a good fit for me. Those of you with less sturdy nails should probably avoid since it does not support the nail, only cover it. It’s been hard to communicate with them about the issue as well. This is my real nail gone 😔😞
