Goodfellas Pizzeria - Distillery

Stoner's Pizza Joint in Lexington is a locally owned pizza restaurant at 547 S Limestone. Reviews highlight cheezy, scrumptious pizzas, breadsticks, cookies, and cold drinks, with fast delivery and busy take-out service. Dine-in is limited to about 4-5 seats, making take-out or delivery the focus. Staff praise includes friendly hospitality from team members like shift leader Dallas. Delivery is commonly via DoorDash.

Pies & Pints - Lexington, KY serves pizza and beer in a downtown setting at 401 W Main St, Suite 106. The menu features creative pizzas, including Thai shrimp with curry sauce and margarita, with gluten-free crust options. Guests praise light, crisp crusts, flavorful toppings, attentive service, and a wide beer selection on tap in a welcoming atmosphere.

Ethereal Slice House serves New York-Italian inspired pizzas in Lexington, featuring crispy crusts, flavorful sauces, and fresh toppings. Guests highlight Rebecca's welcoming service, prompt timing, and a casual, spacious interior. Signature pies include old world-style drunken mushroom and Brooklyn-style creations, paired with garlic knots and house-made dressings. Beer flights and pizza-by-the-slice options add variety near UK Campus.

Rosati's Pizza in Lexington delivers true Chicago-style pizza, featuring standout deep-dish pies and a bold, savory sauce. Customers praise authentic flavors, a clean, welcoming atmosphere, and friendly staff, calling it a genuine Chicago experience. The restaurant offers delivery and catering from 148 Malabu Dr Suite 160, Lexington, KY 40503.

PieTana in Lexington offers fresh, made-to-order pizza and a menu that includes sandwiches in a welcoming atmosphere. Guests praise friendly staff and attentive service (Sam and Isabella noted), fresh ingredients, and flavorful pies. Outdoor seating is available, with fire-roasted wings and a salad with asparagus praised by diners. A true local gem near Rosemont Garden.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street in Lexington serves pizza by the slice or whole pie with fresh ingredients and a sweet sauce on a thin crust. Reviewers praise quick service, a lively, snazzy atmosphere, and a dough-flipping show. Many call it Lexington’s best pizza and an option for salads, though some peak-time visits note slower service or variable slice quality.