Pies & Pints - Lexington, KY

Stoner's Pizza Joint in Lexington is a locally owned pizza restaurant at 547 S Limestone. Reviews highlight cheezy, scrumptious pizzas, breadsticks, cookies, and cold drinks, with fast delivery and busy take-out service. Dine-in is limited to about 4-5 seats, making take-out or delivery the focus. Staff praise includes friendly hospitality from team members like shift leader Dallas. Delivery is commonly via DoorDash.

Ethereal Slice House serves New York-Italian inspired pizzas in Lexington, featuring crispy crusts, flavorful sauces, and fresh toppings. Guests highlight Rebecca's welcoming service, prompt timing, and a casual, spacious interior. Signature pies include old world-style drunken mushroom and Brooklyn-style creations, paired with garlic knots and house-made dressings. Beer flights and pizza-by-the-slice options add variety near UK Campus.

Rosati's Pizza in Lexington delivers true Chicago-style pizza, featuring standout deep-dish pies and a bold, savory sauce. Customers praise authentic flavors, a clean, welcoming atmosphere, and friendly staff, calling it a genuine Chicago experience. The restaurant offers delivery and catering from 148 Malabu Dr Suite 160, Lexington, KY 40503.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Distillery serves pizza in a beautiful, historic Lexington building. Reviews highlight a cozy interior, tasty pies, a strong drink selection, and a one-of-a-kind atmosphere near distilleries. The setting preserves history and adds to the visit. Experiences vary—some praise quick service and flavor, while another review notes long waits and cold pizza.

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street in Lexington serves pizza by the slice or whole pie with fresh ingredients and a sweet sauce on a thin crust. Reviewers praise quick service, a lively, snazzy atmosphere, and a dough-flipping show. Many call it Lexington’s best pizza and an option for salads, though some peak-time visits note slower service or variable slice quality.

PieTana in Lexington offers fresh, made-to-order pizza and a menu that includes sandwiches in a welcoming atmosphere. Guests praise friendly staff and attentive service (Sam and Isabella noted), fresh ingredients, and flavorful pies. Outdoor seating is available, with fire-roasted wings and a salad with asparagus praised by diners. A true local gem near Rosemont Garden.