GP
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street
By the slice or pie, fresh, bold pizza with a lively vibe.
3.8
Pizza
$
By the slice or pie, fresh, bold pizza with a lively vibe.
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street in Lexington serves pizza by the slice or whole pie with fresh ingredients and a sweet sauce on a thin crust. Reviewers praise quick service, a lively, snazzy atmosphere, and a dough-flipping show. Many call it Lexington’s best pizza and an option for salads, though some peak-time visits note slower service or variable slice quality.
No photos available
Freshly baked slices available for quick, affordable meals with daily rotating flavors.
Customizable whole pies made to order with premium ingredients and hand-tossed dough.
Complementary options like fresh salads to pair with your pizza for a complete meal.
Enjoy our lively atmosphere on-site or grab your pizza to go for convenience.
Unique creations including Hawaiian, chicken bacon, and classic pepperoni, all made fresh.
Claim Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
BethAnn Stinnett
BEST pizza in Lexington. Quick service, amazing pizza and I love their salad too. The atmosphere is unique and the vibe is something different for everyone but you’ll wanna tell your friends and come back again and again.
Lisa Hash
My family and I went there after the Halloween parade last night. After waiting in line and finally getting in the restaurant one of the pizza makers had his friends come in and handed them the last of the pepperoni pizza. This wouldn't have been a problem except this is a very busy night. We waited in line and there was no pizza even close to being done to wait for. Not only did this guy give the pizza away for free he compleatly disregarded the paying customers that waited. This was a tradition we have for years now. I will never return to your establishment. Im sure im not the only customer that is upset about this since there was a line and again no pizza was even close to being done. Have a back up plan if you decide to go there. Clearly they DO NOT CARE about business.
Matt Burks
Have been wanting to try Goodfellas ever since I started coming to Lexington annually. I stopped by around 2:00 pm on a Saturday, so there was no wait. I bought two slices; one chicken bacon and one pepperoni. Honestly I found them disappointing. The cheese was overly chewy and rubbery, and both pieces were fairly dry. The chicken bacon aldo didn't taste particularly fresh. The young lady working the counter was very nice.
Lisa Wagner
This place is amazing! You can buy by the slice or get a whole pie. We walked in as they were pulling a fresh one out of the oven. My husband and I both had a slice of Hawaiian and the pizza was so good we went back for another slice of just cheese but was equally as good! Fresh ingredients and seeing the one guy flipping the dough in the air was the best experience. Great guys working there and you can tell they love what they do. Thank you so much for the amazing pizza!
C D
My soul is jumping from happiness. I lived in NJ/NY for 21 years and am very accustomed to their pizza. I bought a slice to try before buying a pie and it was *everything* I could ever want. Sweet sauce, perfect amount of grease, thin, awesome size, good crust, and made in a snazzy environment. Big recommend!!!
