
Authentic New York-style pizza by the slice or pie, made fresh with passion in Lexington.
No photos available
Goodfellas Pizzeria on Mill Street brings a taste of New York to Lexington with its authentic, hand-tossed pizzas. We specialize in fresh, high-quality ingredients and offer both by-the-slice convenience and whole pies for any occasion. Our lively atmosphere features dough-flipping displays and a unique vibe that pizza lovers adore. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a meal with friends, we're committed to delivering delicious, satisfying pizza that keeps customers coming back. Located at 110 N Mill St, we're your go-to spot for classic and creative pizza options.
Freshly baked slices available for quick, affordable meals with daily rotating flavors.
Customizable whole pies made to order with premium ingredients and hand-tossed dough.
Complementary options like fresh salads to pair with your pizza for a complete meal.
Enjoy our lively atmosphere on-site or grab your pizza to go for convenience.
Unique creations including Hawaiian, chicken bacon, and classic pepperoni, all made fresh.
No reviews yet. Be the first to leave a review!
Claim Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.