M
Mikey's Late Night Slice
Columbus' go-to spot for authentic NYC-style pizza, served fresh until the early hours.
5(5 reviews)
$
pizza
other-business
About Mikey's Late Night Slice
Mikey's Late Night Slice is a beloved Columbus institution specializing in authentic, thin-crust NYC-style pizza. Located just steps from Nationwide Arena, we're the perfect pre- or post-game stop, offering generous slices, whole pies, and delicious sides like cheesy garlic bread. Our vegan options, including BBQ chicken pizza, are so good even non-vegans rave about them. With a self-serve dipping sauce station, friendly service, and a vibrant atmosphere, we deliver that classic New York pizza experience right in the heart of Ohio. Open late to satisfy your cravings.
Business Info
Location
457 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215, USA
Services Offered
NYC-Style Pizza by the Slice
Fresh, thin-crust pizza with perfect cheese-to-sauce ratios, available by the slice or whole pie.
Vegan Pizza Options
Delicious vegan pizzas like BBQ chicken that appeal to all, not just those following a plant-based diet.
Cheesy Garlic Bread
A popular side dish, baked to perfection with garlic and melted cheese.
Dipping Sauce Station
Self-serve station with a variety of sauces to complement your pizza, available for purchase to-go.
Late-Night Dining
Open into the early hours, ideal for post-concert, game, or night-out cravings.
Takeout & Dine-In
Enjoy our vibrant atmosphere on-site or grab your pizza to go for convenience.
Reviews
5(5 reviews)
Rating Distribution
5
5
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0
N
Nicole Green
via Google
22 days ago
We were in the area for a Blue Jackets game, I had only had Mikeys at concerts in Columbus and didnt realize they had a store front so close to Nationwide. This will 100% be our stop before every game now! We got the vegan BBQ chicken pizza and the cheesy garlic bread (neither of us are vegan, it just looked really good). The pizza was incredible and I wouldn't have even known it was vegan if they didnt tell us. Love that they have a dipping sauce station and you can buy the sauces to go. Crust was perfect and service was friendly and efficient. Cant wait to go back!
L
Lisa Guzmanvia Google
4 months ago
I got 2 free slices of pizza from here during the National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC) 🙌🏼 I came back the second day & paid for a slice & a fountain drink. Tasty food both times!
I
ILEANA AGOSTINIvia Google
5 months ago
This place I would give an 6 out of 5 stars that google allows because as a native New Yorker, the vibe was immaculate, from the music and service staff who were patient, friendly and helpful. Now the food, let me preface by saying I’m a pizza snob and the pizza here was delicious very close to a NYC style pizza! When you’re in Columbus, Ohio DEFINITELY go visit and get yourself a slice or pie!
L
Lee Strz (ExceptionL)via Google
5 months ago
I'm Google maps David Portnoy without all the weird stuff. A guy who loves good pizza, and enjoys being overly opinionated.. I'm damn good at it too. Let me say this pizza didn't disappoint. I came here with high expectations after being told by a local at my hotel that it was the best pizza in town. A mere stroll, 15 minutes from my hotel would lead me on the path to pizza paradise. I got the pepperoni and the spicy pepperoni. Both were very thin, with perfect ratios of cheese toppings and dough. Extremely soft dough without any flop, firm but with great chew, texture. Buttery, garlicky goodness. The sauce and for me the most important part of a good pizza was a hit. Not overly sugary or sweet, but balanced with that fresh marinara tomato 🍅 greatness. Even the crust was soft, and delivered it's assignment with a knowledge unlike majority of pizzas. I was full with two slices albeit their thin and not overbearing size but I had to get one more slice anyway against my stomachs better judgement. My heart was not satisfied and my mind had justified on an emotional whim that I am never be in this town again or at this pizza joint. Still in glad I did. I'm sure the 15 minute walk back didn't cancel out that third slice. Easily one of the best pizzas I've had in the entire USA.
J
Jeremy Allenvia Google
5 months ago
Arguably the best slice of NYC style pizza I’ve had both in and out of the city. Pizza Rat might end up moving to Columbus… Really fresh complex flavors and I appreciate the “or not” variations. Hot Take, NYC could use one more slice shop…
