Paulie Gee's Columbus: Bold pizzas with standout vegan options and perfect crust.
Paulie Gee's Columbus serves Italian-inspired pizzas with strong vegan options at 1195 N High St. Reviewers praise crust that stays chewy and not soggy, from Just Like Heaven to square pies. The vegan lineup includes ricotta pizzas and a dough pillow option. Attentive service and popular Wednesday deals, like three pies for $45, draw repeat visits.
1195 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201, USA
Claim Paulie Gee's to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
Handcrafted pizzas with perfect crust, including Detroit-style square pies and classic Neapolitan options.
Dedicated plant-based menu with innovative toppings like vegan ricotta and sausage alternatives.
Three vegan pizzas for $45 every Wednesday, offering great value on fan-favorite pies.
A unique side item featuring our signature dough, optionally vegan with olive oil instead of butter.
Curated selection of beers, wines, and cocktails to complement your meal.
Overall rating
Bobby Truong
!⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐! Paulie Gee’s Columbus is absolutely amazing. The Just Like Heaven pizza was perfectly made — not soggy at all, with the perfect chewiness. Every bite was balanced and delicious. It was so good I came back twice in one week, which says everything. Easily one of the best pizzas in Columbus. Can’t wait to go back again.
Jessica Wilson
I’ve eaten plenty of pizza in my life, including many Detroit style pizzas since I live in Michigan. Paulie Gee’s square pizza was the best pizza I have ever had in my life, swear to god. We had the pepperoni and burrata one and we fought over the last piece. Absolutely incredible. The place fills up so get there early but it is worth any wait I promise you. Prompt & friendly service as well but the square pizza is the star here.
Thomas Allen
Just an amazing meal. The pizza is to die for. Top 3 of all the margheritas we have had. And another (forgot the name) was just as good. A must-visit for sure.
Goose Rodriguez
Paulie Gee’s has the best vegan pizza in town IMHO and they have 3 pies for $45 on Wednesdays. Pictured. Jeb’s garden. Simply red. In ricotta da Vida. Vegan supreme
Samantha Baxter
This place has the best vegan pizza we've ever had. The crust/dough is phenomenal--so good they have a unique item (the dough pillow, which can be vegan if you sub the butter for olive oil) so you can eat it by itself! We got the vegan ricotta, sausage and arugula pizza, which was amazing. The ricotta was particularly good. I can't believe they weren't packed at lunchtime on a Saturday! Bobby took care of us and was super attentive. We'll definitely be back!
