LO
Lucia's On The Lake
Lucia's On The Lake: Italian classics with lakeside charm and a celebrated wine list.
4.8
Italian
$$$
Lucia's On The Lake: Italian classics with lakeside charm and a celebrated wine list.
Lucia's On The Lake offers Italian-inspired fare with steak, seafood, and American options in a bright, lakeside setting in Hamburg, NY. Guests praise attentive service, a well-curated wine and cocktail selection, and standout dishes like French onion soup with Gruyère, lobster truffle ravioli, tomahawk steak, and blackened chicken risotto. The owner actively oversees the restaurant, contributing to a welcoming, lively atmosphere.
No photos available
Enjoy expertly crafted Italian dishes like risotto, ravioli, and stuffed peppers in an upscale setting.
Savor perfectly cooked steaks, including the Tomahawk, using high-quality cuts and precise preparation.
Indulge in fresh seafood options such as salmon, scallops, and bang bang shrimp, sourced for quality.
Explore an extensive selection of wines and creative cocktails, including lemon drop martinis and blackberry St. Germain.
Celebrate anniversaries or gatherings with personalized service, reservations, and a memorable lakeside ambiance.
Claim Lucia's On The Lake to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Margaret Colligan
This was my first time dining here ever, which is wild considering I’ve lived in Hamburg almost my whole life—I must have been living under a rock! We had a later reservation, so the atmosphere was relaxed and inviting when we arrived. The staff was friendly right from the moment we walked in, and I noticed the owner actively overseeing the restaurant, which I think is so important in the food service industry. It really shows care for both the staff and the business. Our server, Jared, was fantastic and extremely knowledgeable about the menu. We started with the French onion soup and it was AMAZING—made with Gruyère instead of the usual provolone or Havarti, which made all the difference. The cheese pull was unreal! The bread with the dip sampler was also a great touch—super cute and delicious. I ordered the blackberry St. Germain cocktail and it was just as impressive. For my entrée, it was hard to choose because everything sounded so good, but I went with the lobster truffle ravioli and added three scallops with the pomegranate glaze. Every bite was spectacular. Overall, an incredible experience—I will definitely be back!
Ray Katta
Too loud. Took a long time to get the meals. Granted though, it was extremely busy and our waitress comped us with dessert. Filet mignon was cooked perfectly.
Amy Lynn MAGS
Went here for dinner with my cousins. Im not a drinker but they did have nice selection of wines and cocktails for my family. The menu is smaller but the food we did have was outstanding. I highly recommend the French onion soup and stuffed peppers. The atmosphere is a tad loud but that cannot be helped as the resturant and bar are busy. Our server was very attentive and friendly.
Jennifer Stoklosa
My husband and I visited Lucia's for the first time to celebrate our 16th anniversary. Walking in the restaurant was bright and full of light from the windows. We were greeted as soon as we walked in and were seated immediately (we had a reservation). I ordered the lemon drop martini which was refreshing and easily the best lemon martini I've ever had. My husband, looking for a dry red wine, ordered a glass of the driest red, at the recommendation of the server, which he said was delicious. He ordered the Tomahawk steak which he loved and said was perfectly cooked. I got the blackened chicken risotto. This may have been one of my favorite dishes I've ordered in a restaurant - I'm still thinking about it a day later. I highly recommend Lucia's for great service and an amazing meal.
Liz E
My husband and I went for dinner for our 3rd wedding anniversary / our 10 years of being together. The food, the service, the everything was amazing!!! The restaurant dining area is a little tight, but it's so work the experience!!! We had a bottle of wine, the bang bang shrimp, the salmon, the tomahawk steak, and dessert!!! As a chef, I was absolutely blown away with how amazing the food was!!! Fresh, delicious, 10/10!!
