Fire-kissed pizza and bar vibes in Buffalo.
Hearth + Press is a Buffalo pizza restaurant at 665 Main St, serving pizza, pasta, hummus, and burrata from a wood-fired oven. Guests often praise the bar, the flavorful pizzas, and attentive bartenders, while some visits note seating delays or slower service. The overall vibe is welcoming and flavorful, making it a popular stop for pizza lovers in Buffalo.
665 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14203, USA
Claim Hearth + Press to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
Handcrafted pizzas with fresh ingredients, baked in an authentic pizza oven for a crisp, flavorful crust.
Starters like hummus, burrata, and garlic bread, perfect for sharing before your main course.
Hearty pasta options, including eggplant and tomato sauce, made with care for a satisfying meal.
Fresh salads featuring ingredients like chicken or shrimp, ideal for a lighter dining choice.
Curated list of wines, such as Pinot Grigio, and beers like Guinness to complement your meal.
Cozy seating with a warm ambiance, suitable for dinners, dates, or group outings in Buffalo.
Overall rating
Augusta Mead
Hearth + Press is always my go to before a show downtown. Saturday night did not disappoint. Surprisingly it was a quiet Saturday afternoon. We had made a reservation but definitely had not needed to. I had the Traditional White Pizza and my sister in law had the Shrimp Penne. I would say I liked her penne better than my pizza, but I was going out of my comfort zone (normally I’m a basic Margherita girlie). Great spot with good vibes and good food!
Brittany
eric ensminger
Happened to be in the neighborhood around lunch and was recommended the pizza here. I was warmly welcomed and my questions were answered quickly and completely. Ordered a couple of slices, each different "specialty" pizzas from the menu. They were terrific! The cook even provided me a sample of the soup for the day. Amazing. Everything about this restaurant was great; the music, the service, the food. Will definitely be going again.
Jill Bernstein
About the food was good but not really anything special and prices were high because of the location. Really nice atmosphere though and we had a great server. So I have no complaints I just think that for what you got it was pricey.
Armani Merlino
The pizza is very good, can't speak to the quality of the other menu items. Check the schedule for Shea's before going, it will be very busy when a show is going on. When there aren't any shows currently playing, or when the place just opens for dinner, there won't be a wait. The atmosphere is romantic and a bit dim.
Martha R
I love the fact that, that the owner bakes his own bread, makes the Best Meatballs and Sauce... A Must Eat! Absolutely Friendly ☺️ Great staff I Love The Pizza!!!!!
