Osteria 166

Hearth + Press is a Buffalo pizza restaurant at 665 Main St, serving pizza, pasta, hummus, and burrata from a wood-fired oven. Guests often praise the bar, the flavorful pizzas, and attentive bartenders, while some visits note seating delays or slower service. The overall vibe is welcoming and flavorful, making it a popular stop for pizza lovers in Buffalo.

JJs Casa Di Pizza in Buffalo offers deep-dish pizza, wings, and a wide beer selection in a cozy, welcoming setting. Located at 11 E Mohawk St, the restaurant also provides catering with reliable, on-time delivery and complete setups. Customers highlight friendly staff, quick service, and a hometown vibe, plus sports on TVs and an LGBTQ-safe, inclusive space.

Frankie Primo's +39 offers classic Italian dining in Buffalo, featuring fresh, flavorful dishes and attentive service. Guests praise gnocci and chicken/eggplant parm, along with mushrooms in velvety sauces and braised beef with hazelnuts. The old-fashioned wood bar and warm dining area, plus outdoor seating and a full bar, deliver welcoming hospitality with half portions.

Chef's Restaurant in Buffalo delivers old-school Italian dining with huge portions, including its signature spaghetti parm and made-in-house bread. The dining room feels like a history book, with photos from the 100+ year legacy and plenty of character. Service is praised as friendly, and guests can purchase sauces and gift sets, plus bib napkins—reservations are recommended for busy times.

Bflo Pizza Bistro sits at 388 Porter Ave in Buffalo, delivering Buffalo-style, thick-but-airy pies and fresh, ingredient-forward dishes. Diners praise the chopped salad with a grated cheese topper, the Augie pizza, the mushroom pie, and gluten-free options, all with bold San Marzano sauce. Outdoor seating with picnic tables invites relaxed meals. Seasonal pizzas are inventive, and service is friendly, making this hidden gem a local favorite.

Named Tappo Restaurant, this Buffalo Italian spot blends warm lighting and a friendly atmosphere with a diverse menu of pasta, seafood, and classic Italian dishes. Guests praise attentive service, a lively patio vibe for summer happy hours, a solid wine list, and standout cocktails like Gold Rush. The space features couches, a bar, and occasional live music, making it a welcoming destination for casual dinners or date nights.