Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop

P

Peter Sparbervia Google

about 2 months ago

The real Michelin stars!!! We returned to PG's a couple weeks after posting the (original 3-star) review about the take-out slices in the photo. The owner reached out and wanted to make it right...but we insisted on remaining anonymous and just wanted PG's to make sure they were making it right day-in-day-out. On that next visit we again ordered two take out Freddie Prinz slices and they were magnificent. We take them home and later re-heat them until they get a little burnt on top. Those slices, along with the chicken wings at Koreana, are two of the great flavor experiences in Philly. Thick, cheesy, saucy, chewy, crispy-burnt...they can send you into that special blissed-out zone. Good work PG. ============ (original review below)=========== Not up to the usual standard. Paulie Gee's has been our 'go to' pizza place since we moved (back) to Philly a few years ago. The regular pie is great, but the Freddie Prinz has always been a stand-out. A big...thick...saucy...cheesy delight. Unfortunately today we got a couple slices for take-out and got an unpleasant surprise when we got home and opened the box. The slices were about 20-25% smaller and a lot thinner (not sure if that shows up in the attached photo). It's just always disappointing when a really good place is consistent...but then inconsistent. Please don't let this happen and get back on track...we need to know PG's will be there when we need them! Thanks.

J

Jim Bongardvia Google

2 months ago

Great place for slices and a beverage. There is an ancient Atari game system with a vintage console TV. A box with LP's for sale. A great dive bar - and I mean that in the most Complimentary way possible. The food was terrific 💯👍

A

Alex Newtonvia Google

3 months ago

Delicious pizza, great vibes, friendly service. Great place to grab a slice and a beer on the way home after an early night out. Big fan of the hot honey + sesame crust on the Hellboy2. Drinks are great, rotating taps. Retro vibe and chill crowd.

T

Trey Delaplainevia Google

3 months ago

I really loved this place! Affordable prices for outstanding pizza. It seemed like a cool place to hangout. I was visiting from the west coast, so I was there alone. But if I lived in the area or was visiting with friends, it would be a cool place to hangout late night and grab some pizza and drinks. I will say one critique is I noticed a fly in the glass case where the pizzas are kept 😂 but Im still giving this place 5 stars, it was really good service and really good food for good prices. Will definitely come back if Im back in the area.

K

Keeksvia Google

4 months ago

One of the top pizzas in Philadelphia. Everything is cooked perfectly in the oven. My favorite is absolutely the square focaccia pie with honey crusted pepperoni. I don’t think I’ve found an equivalent yet in Philly. Even my Italian friend agrees this is the best pizza place in the city. We ate at the bar. Bartender was very attentive to us. There’s also arcade games and billiard available. Will come back again!