Sebastiano's Italiano

E

Emily Mitchell

via Google

I’ve been going to this restaurant for years and I love it so much. The family owned aspect of it feels so homey, and they really care about their customers, quality food, and overall service of the restaurant. Everything on the menu is fantastic and it’s probably the best pasta I’ve ever had. There is no other Italian restaurant in Toledo that is better than this one! I also love the small atmosphere. They have one chef and one sous chef in the kitchen. Even though it’s small, they put all of their heart into cooking. The servers are always so kind and polite. And it’s always fun having their kiddos come visit! I can’t say enough how much I love Sebastiano’s, this paragraph doesn’t do the restaurant justice. Go experience it for yourself! They do only reservations since the restaurant is so small, but it works very well and the person on the phone is always polite. I always have a great time at Sebastiano’s!

B

Belinda Goldsmith

via Google

I came in the other night. I called ahead if I could get a table for one and she said if I came before a certain time. I asked if I could do take out annd was told that wasn’t offered. No biggie. Everything went well… ordered a cran vodka and spaghetti. I then ask for my to go box because I was planning on eating my meal on camera. I ask if she takes Apple Pay and she says yes. But then… she says she needs to walk with me to pay for my food. I’m so confused as to why she would need to walk with me to pay. I then tell her fine, I’ll come pay for my food before I even box it up or even get a box for my food. I go to pay and I ask her if it was standard protocol to tell guest they need to walk with staff to pay. She made up some excuses and tried to make it seem that I was asking to pay right then and not when I was actually leaving. Will not be back. The food tasted highly quality and very affordable. Drink was made perfectly. Best meatballs I’ve ever had hands down. I was highly embarrassed and did not post the food as a mukbang on my TikTok channel after getting tons of recommendations. Idk if it was because of my alternative appearance that she thought I was planning on dining and dashing. But it’s completely unacceptable. I even tipped her for her services but wish I never spent my money in this establishment to be profiled

J

Joshow 74

via Google

Definitely a diamond in the rough! We were in from Sandusky for a show and chose it based off their reviews on here. Make a reservation, the place is small but fills in quick. The spinach and artichoke appetizer is a must have. Definitely different than your run of the mill spinach artichoke dip from chain restaurants. Menu is also nice as while there are some normal dishes you can get elsewhere there are numerous original dishes that stand out from the crowd. We will definitely keep this place in mind when going to the Stranahan. Thanks for a great night out!

S

Susan Johnson

via Google

Excellent food, exceptional service from beginning to end, and inviting ambiance. "Our waitress gave an outstanding performance during our visit. The restaurant was busy, but she handled our large table of five with incredible poise. Instead of using a notepad, she took everyone's orders--including all the custom modifications--from memory. When the food arrived, every single dish was perfectly correct. It was an impressive and memorable display of professionalism. A big shout out to the staff for having such dedicated and talented servers!".

J

Julia Karney

via Google

Pretty good Italian restaurant! We had spinach artichoke dip to start, and the flavor was great, but it was quite runny. The bread that came with the dip was amazing too! The gnocchi and other pasta dish were good. Wish it was a touch fancier, but overall a fine dinner experience.