S
Show Me Pizza
Where Austin's creativity meets authentic Neapolitan pizza—crafted with passion and flavor.
4.2(5 reviews)
$
restaurant
italian
gluten-free
1 / 10
About Show Me Pizza
Show Me Pizza is a beloved Austin pizzeria serving inventive Neapolitan-style pizzas with a fun, adventurous twist. Located at 2809 S 1st St, we specialize in creative toppings, homemade sauces, and perfect dough, offering options like gluten-free crusts and unique combos like Cashville Hot Chicken. With a 4.7-star rating, we provide a charming, vibrant atmosphere for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, making every slice a memorable experience for pizza lovers and families alike.
Business Info
Location
2809 S 1st St, Austin, TX 78704, USA
Services Offered
Neapolitan Pizza
Handcrafted pizzas with authentic dough, fresh ingredients, and creative toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and spicy vodka sauce.
Gluten-Free Options
Delicious gluten-free pizzas that taste like the real deal, perfect for dietary needs without compromising flavor.
Specialty Pizzas
Unique flavor combinations such as Cashville Hot Chicken and Domo Arrabiata, featuring homemade sauces and premium toppings.
Dine-In Experience
A fun, charming atmosphere with vibrant decor for enjoying pizza fresh from the oven with friends and family.
Takeout & Delivery
Convenient options for pickup or delivery via services like Uber Eats, bringing our tasty pizzas right to your door.
Reviews
4.2(5 reviews)
Rating Distribution
5
4
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
1
T
Tiger Im
via Google
about 1 month ago
If you want creative, flavorful Neapolitan pizza, this should be on your radar. If Bufalina is where you go for more fancy, traditional tomato sauce based Neapolitan pizzas, then this is where you go when you're feeling more adventurous and fun-loving. We had 3 pizzas. The first one was the 50 First Dates. Liked the toppings on this one. Second was the Domo Arrabiata Mr. Roboto, which had an assortment of textures and flavors we enjoyed. The spiciness from the sauce & chili oil perfectly cut through the savory meat and sweet honey. Last, we had the Cashville Hot Chicken (not pictured bc we got too excited to eat it). This one was probably our favorite. Slightly crispy, savory, hot chicken with nice brightness from the pickled onions. The pizza can get a bit soggy, but that's par for the course for Neapolitan. Overall, the flavor combos were fun and nicely executed. Great toppings, sauce (Arrabiata in particular), and tasty cheese (cheese pulls included!). Loved how charmingly fun the decor is and the owner, Benjamin, was awesome. We loved talking to him & his effortless charm. Come give this place some love!
B
Blaik Romovia Google
about 2 months ago
New favorite pizza spot! The pizza was even better than the ones I had in Italy a month ago. Somehow these guys figured out the secret recipe to the perfect dough, sauce & cheese ratio. We got a traditional pepperoni which far passed my expectations. It had crispy deli pepperoni, fresh oregano leaves and tons of cheese. We also got a sausage pizza with their homemade onion sauce because it sounded interesting. It was even better than the 1st pizza somehow. Great pizza, great vibes, nice location. You gotta try this spot
D
Demi Hunterovia Google
3 months ago
Not one to write reviews but my experience had to shared for others to know. I ordered 2 pizzas for delivery from Uber Eats. The Carbone Copy and Duck Side of the Moon. Had asked for the Carbone Copy to have extra char, but from the looks of it, had the same amount of char as the Duck pizza. On top of that, my first bite into the Duck pizza revealed a bone. If they’re doing the job of deboning the duck meat as opposed to getting meat thats already deboned, they need to do a better job of job. And I have ordered from here before, read the reviews about soggy, floppy pizza before but chose not to listen to them. Terrible mistake because amongst all my other troubles with these pizzas today, they’re exactly as some other people have described. The entire experience has been awful, and Im positive I can spend that type of money elsewhere for better quality.
K
Kaitlin Huppinvia Google
3 months ago
Best gluten free gf pizza I’ve ever had in my life. Don’t think this can be topped!! It was like… like real pizza! Check out the crumb. I got the Carbone Copy Spicy Vodka and added pepperoni. Wish I lived in Austin, I’d come here all the time!
S
Santiago Vidalvia Google
4 months ago
Honestly this is the best pizza that I’ve had in Austin. My fiancée and I ordered the vodka sauce pizza and pepperoni pizza and it came out delicious. I liked my pepperoni pizza so much that when my fiancée asked for a slice, I truly had to think about it for a second because I wanted the whole pie! Can’t wait to be back (for my own pie😊)
