The Sicilian Guy: Authentic Sicilian-Italian comfort with homemade bread and bold flavors in Jersey City.
Located at 211 Newark Ave, The Sicilian Guy serves authentic Sicilian-Italian comfort food in Jersey City. Customers praise generous portions, flavorful sauces, and freshly baked bread that accompanies many dishes. Menu items mentioned in reviews include cold chicken cutlet sandwich, meatball parm and sausage and peppers hot sandwiches, baked ziti, lasagne, stuffed peppers, soup, and pistachio cannoli. The owner is friendly and accommodating.
211 Newark Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07302, USA
Claim The Sicilian Guy to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
Freshly baked subs with options like cold chicken cutlet, meatball parm, and sausage and peppers.
Traditional dishes including baked ziti, lasagne, and stuffed peppers, all made from scratch.
Hearty soups served by the quart with a loaf of bread, plus sides like eggplant and ziti.
Authentic Sicilian treats such as pistachio cannoli, perfect for ending your meal.
Convenient takeout options and catering services for events and family gatherings.
Overall rating
Cristina Kovalik
Real Italian comfort food. I can tell that the owner put lots of care and passion into their product from the quality of the food I received. For example, I could tell the bread for the sub was freshly baked. You will definitely get bang for buck here. I only got two menu items and I think this will last me a few meals. I am so happy to have another local restaurant open in downtown JC!
Brian Mccall
Such a great spot. I’ve tried their incredible soup, which for a quart is a huge value. Plus you get a loaf of bread. I’ve also tried their pastas and eggplant. Both of which also come with the homemade bread. The owner is super helpful, and very friendly. When pondering what I wanted to eat, he’d offer samples. He’s confident in his cooking, and he should be - it’s all very delicious. A great find!
Victoria Cortese
My fiancé and I finally tried the Sicilian Guy after always passing it on Newark and OMG the food is unreal! We got the cold chicken cutlet sandwich for lunch and then the stuffed peppers and lasagne for dinner. Everything was incredible and the sauce had so much flavor! We ended up going back a couple days later to try their hot sandwiches, splitting the meatball parm and sausage and peppers. Again, everything was absolutely incredible! The owner was so kind and let us try some of the ziti he just made. We will definitely be back to try the kick ass soup 😄
S I
the food was divine and the service was top notch. I called ahead to see if they had space for us and they were so accommodating. I got the half chicken and half meatball sandwich and a sicilian pistachio cannoli. 10/10 recommend
Christopher Curti
Finally getting a true Italian staple in the neighborhood is very exciting, but a SICILIAN specialized spot makes an Italian-American kid’s dream come true. I got the Baked Ziti and the Focaccia-Family Sunday sauce is a sacred thing, I would bring my mom here. Absolutely delicious.
