Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar

Mario's Pizza in Winston-Salem serves pizza and Italian favorites at 1066 Hanes Mall Blvd. Customers praise a sweet sauce that supports the cheese, a thin, crispy crust with a hint of dusting, and fresh, locally made ingredients. The menu features daily specials and convenient takeout in a welcoming, casual setting.

Grandpa Joe's Slaberia delivers bold slab pizzas on thick, crispy focaccia, topped with favorites like Italian sausage, pepperoni, and burrata. The menu also features fresh salads, tiramisu, and homemade ice cream. Housed in a beautifully restored Coca-Cola bottling factory in Winston-Salem, it offers ample indoor and outdoor seating, including a sunny courtyard and accessible facilities. Patrons praise friendly service, creative slabs, and a welcoming, casual-elevated vibe.

Burke Street Pizza Burke St. in Winston-Salem serves classic New York–style pizza with a crispy crust and a soft, pillowy center. The menu features slices, whole pies, garlic knots, fried ravioli, wings, and salads, all made to order. Reviews highlight generous toppings, affordable prices, hot, fresh food, and a welcoming, neighborhood vibe—perfect for quick slices or family meals.

Located at 314 W 4th St in downtown Winston-Salem, Mellow Mushroom Winston-Salem showcases specialty pizzas, vegan and vegetarian options, wings, and a diverse drink menu. Reviews highlight friendly, efficient service, a fun vibe, and multiple seating choices, making it a solid choice for groups. Downtown parking can be limited, and experiences may vary on menu items.

Brothers Pizzeria in Winston-Salem, NC, at 214 W 4th St, offers pizzas ranging from NY-style to Sicilian, with a sauce noted for balance and flavor. The dining room features local art and an old-school rock vibe, and the brick-oven crust with hand-rolled dough delivers crisp texture. Reviews praise friendly owners and staff, fair pricing for quality, and memorable visits, while one delivery review notes issues with salt and meat toppings.

Cugino Forno Pizzeria Winston Salem serves acclaimed Neapolitan pizzas praised for an outstanding crust, premium cheese, and evenly distributed toppings. Reviews highlight gelato and fresh salads, plus ample indoor and outdoor seating in a rustic industrial setting. Some diners note a strict no-customization policy, yet the pizza quality remains a standout and has earned national recognition.