BP
Brothers Pizzeria
Brothers Pizzeria: From NY-style to Sicilian pies, brick-oven flavor with local art and a welcoming vibe.
4
Pizza
$$
Brothers Pizzeria: From NY-style to Sicilian pies, brick-oven flavor with local art and a welcoming vibe.
Brothers Pizzeria in Winston-Salem, NC, at 214 W 4th St, offers pizzas ranging from NY-style to Sicilian, with a sauce noted for balance and flavor. The dining room features local art and an old-school rock vibe, and the brick-oven crust with hand-rolled dough delivers crisp texture. Reviews praise friendly owners and staff, fair pricing for quality, and memorable visits, while one delivery review notes issues with salt and meat toppings.
No photos available
Hand-stretched thin-crust pizza with classic toppings, baked in brick ovens for authentic flavor and texture.
Thick, square-cut pizza with a fluffy crust, perfect for sharing and loaded with fresh ingredients.
Freshly made calzones stuffed with cheese, meats, and veggies, baked to golden perfection—a small feeds two easily.
Enjoy our cozy, art-filled dining room with local artwork, great music, and a fun old-school rock atmosphere.
Convenient takeout and delivery options for enjoying our delicious pizzas and more from the comfort of your home.
Claim Brothers Pizzeria to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
TW Hutch
Brother's Pizza is the best pizza in the heart of downtown Winston-Salem. They make all different types of pizza, NY style to Sicilian and more. Their sauce is out of this world, a great balance of tomato and ingredients. I suggest the Calzone, a small will feel 2 people easily. Check them out, you won't regret it!
Helen Robinson
Best pizza in Winston! The owners & employees are all amazing. The dining room is filled with art made by a local artist! Great food, great music & wonderful people
Corey Everett
I got delivery and did not go there, so I can't say anything about the atmosphere. The pizza was over salted and the all meat pizza didn't taste like anytime but ham. Too much sauce on it as well. I forced two slices down thinking I'd get used to it but I didn't and I threw away the rest of the $40 pizza. Sometimes mom and pop shops are gimmicks and that's what this place is. I would not try anything else on there menu as they can't get a simple pie correct.
Natashya S
Super fun old school rock vibe. Love that it was decorated with local art. Pizza baked by real brick stones to get that delicious crisp texture. Dough hand rolled and stretched, old fashioned. Family from Italy and New Jersey!
Brandon Fortune
First time trying Brothers, and let me tell you what! They made my Birthday night a great one! They are fair with the price for the quality. They get things done right! This place is a must try when you come by the area. You won’t be disappointed! Thank you Brothers Pizza, you have earned my trust and loyalty! 5 stars all the way around the board
