Extra Extra Pizza: thin-crust perfection with a warm, communal vibe.
Extra Extra Pizza in Buffalo invites guests to savor thin-crust pizzas with a crisp bottom and a friendly, attentive staff. The menu shines with salads, meatballs, and house-made ice cream, plus a bar offering beer and wine. The space hosts community events like wine tastings, highlighting a welcoming vibe that keeps locals returning for flavorful pies and a neighborhood atmosphere.
549 W Utica St, Buffalo, NY 14213, USA
Claim Extra Extra Pizza to manage your storefront, respond to reviews, and receive customer leads.
Handcrafted pizzas with a crispy, charred crust, featuring classics like pepperoni and margherita, plus specialty toppings.
Fresh salads, house-made meatballs, and garlic cheese bread, perfect for starting your meal.
Full bar offering a solid selection of beers, wines, and non-alcoholic drink options to complement your pizza.
Delicious homemade ice cream and desserts, including brownies, for a sweet finish to your visit.
Unique experiences like wine tastings with snack pairings, leveraging our space for community-focused events.
Flexible service options with a cozy sit-down atmosphere or convenient takeout for fresh pizza on the go.
Overall rating
Madeline Apperson
Every second spent here—and every bite—is delicious and memorable. The pizza is truly unmatched, and somehow you leave feeling full without feeling weighed down or nap-ready. Pro tip: start with the salad and meatballs, and do not skip the specialty bleu cheese for dunking the za. Amazing drink options too, including a solid list of N/A choices, which makes it a great spot for everyone. P.S. The homemade ice cream is chef’s kiss. Absolute must.
Corina Simba
The experience is always great, we've ordered here a dozen of times, we prefer to sit in so the pizza is extra fresh, I won't go to another pizza shop that's how good it is, the workers are so nice and notice so much! Bread on the house for a long wait, how nice and tentative is that, you can't go wrong. If your thinking about coming here. Do. It. Pepperoni pizza with banana peppers. 🤤🤤🤤
Megan Battista
Attended an adorable and really well run wine tasting at Extra Extra Pizza yesterday- the snack/wine pairings were top notch, the atmosphere was perfect despite being almost entirely uncultured when it comes to wine and the bathroom was SO WELL STOCKED for community needs (ibuprofen, wine wipes, mints AND diapers?! In this economy? What a gift!) The pizza involved in the wine snack plate was outrageously good and I love how they are leveraging their space to incorporate community partners. I'm going to be thinking about this brownie/dessert situation long beyond today. Can't wait to go back on a normal day!
Isabel
If you’re looking for thin crust pizza with a nice char, you need to come here! We got a margarita and although I wish there was a more cheese on it, it was absolutely delicious. The salad also exceeded my expectations and the house made meatballs were good. Great vibe of a place too!
The Luna's
Real laid back place deep in the west side of Buffalo. The employees there greet you when you come in and you can either sit yourself or they'll suggest where you can sit, your preference. There are a couple of choices in the menu I went there for the pizza they also have a bar that serves beer and wine and if you like dessert to finish everything off they have soft serve ice cream as well. The pizza was good with a nice and crispy bottom mild sauce sauce almost like a New York style pizza also when with a side order of garlic cheese bread which was also good. I scored this pizza a 7.1 out of 10 Luna's and the cheese garlic bread I scored at 8.2 out of 10 Luna's.
