La Nova

Extra Extra Pizza in Buffalo invites guests to savor thin-crust pizzas with a crisp bottom and a friendly, attentive staff. The menu shines with salads, meatballs, and house-made ice cream, plus a bar offering beer and wine. The space hosts community events like wine tastings, highlighting a welcoming vibe that keeps locals returning for flavorful pies and a neighborhood atmosphere.

Hearth + Press is a Buffalo pizza restaurant at 665 Main St, serving pizza, pasta, hummus, and burrata from a wood-fired oven. Guests often praise the bar, the flavorful pizzas, and attentive bartenders, while some visits note seating delays or slower service. The overall vibe is welcoming and flavorful, making it a popular stop for pizza lovers in Buffalo.

JJs Casa Di Pizza in Buffalo offers deep-dish pizza, wings, and a wide beer selection in a cozy, welcoming setting. Located at 11 E Mohawk St, the restaurant also provides catering with reliable, on-time delivery and complete setups. Customers highlight friendly staff, quick service, and a hometown vibe, plus sports on TVs and an LGBTQ-safe, inclusive space.

Forno Napoli Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Buffalo, NY captures old-world Italian charm with wood-fired pizzas and Italian favorites. Reviews note a welcoming, friendly staff, a small menu packed with big flavor, and premium ingredients. Guests praise the aroma of garlic, olive oil, and basil, homemade desserts like eclairs, and even fresh tiramisu. A must-visit for pizza lovers seeking warmth and superb pies.

Imperial Pizza - Abbott Road serves pizza, wings, and subs at 1035 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY 14220. Guests praise flavorful pizza and wings, with beef on weck noted as outstanding. Some reviews cite friendly service while others report slower bar service. On-site parking and clean bathrooms are mentioned, and the thicker crust with bold seasonings earns strong recommendations.