Hutchins Garage

Cugino Forno Durham brings authentic wood-fired Italian pizza to Durham in a casual, warehouse-style setting. Guests praise crisp, firm crusts and fresh-tasting ingredients, calling the pies among the best they've had. The roomy space offers indoor and outdoor seating with picnic-table dining and a welcoming vibe, plus gelato, desserts, beer, ciders, and a unique make-your-marinara sauce station.

Devil's NY Pizzeria & Restaurant in Durham offers NYC-inspired pizza and a varied menu that includes brunch, vegan/vegetarian options, sandwiches, and lasagna. Guests note a warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly, attentive staff. A standout is a colossal 29-inch pizza made with fresh crust, sauce, and cheese. Generous portions and value-driven pricing keep customers returning.

Located at 410 Blackwell St in Durham, Mellow Mushroom Durham serves pizza, salads, and more, with vegan and vegetarian options and catering. Customers praise friendly, attentive service, a lively atmosphere, and reliable delivery. Reviews note delicious wings and pizza, helpful catering staff, and value for money, whether dining in, taking out, or hosting a catering order.

Durham's Pizzeria Toro showcases wood-fired pizzas with bold, unique and traditional options, including a vegan cashew-cheese pie. Reviews highlight perfectly baked pies, a seasonal pear dessert, and espresso on the dessert menu. The lively, industrial setting features visible pizza prep and a busy bar; some guests note the space can be loud, but service stays strong during peak hours.

Emmy Squared Pizza: Durham sits in the Brightleaf tobacco warehouses' courtyard at 905 W Main St #25A. Diners praise friendly staff, attentive management, and excellent service, with reservations recommended to minimize waits. The Detroit-style menu includes seasonal pies like Seoul Mate and Arc Angel, gluten-free options, and popular burgers and Brussels sprouts salad, with drinks and desserts earning praise.

Pie Pushers is a Durham pizza restaurant known for New York–style, thin-crust pies like pepperoni and Italian, with welcoming service. Reviews describe an upstairs, eclectic dining area as a hidden gem, feature pizzas such as Dan’s, and generous ingredients. Experiences vary, but many praise the quality pizza, friendly staff, and a lively Main Street atmosphere.