N

Nickievia Google

4 months ago

First time here and it was really good. We ordered pepperoni pizza and Italian both were excellent, thin crispy crust reminded me of New York style pizza. Service was great, very welcoming. We enjoyed it, definitely coming back again soon.

C

Crystal Brownvia Google

4 months ago

Where do I begin. Walking up the stairs to the restaurant, there is a horrible stench that smells like sewage. Once I approached the register to retrieve my online order I saw 3 employees. One woman had on pointy ears and was blowing her nose. I was completely grossed out because she could’ve done that in the back. She was also eating on the frontline which is so unprofessional. The only highlight of my pickup was the gentleman helping me. He was very nice. Now on to the food. For what I paid, I’m not going to complain too much. My pepperoni slice was edible. Something is off with the sauce though. The cheese slice went in the trash. Those spots are very crispy and I’m very confused as to why they would serve that to someone. I’d really like a refund. Would I go back? Probably not.

H

Helen Arensvia Google

6 months ago

Ordered take out consisting of pepperoni pizza with mushrooms and onions, and baked chicken wings. Pizza was ready quickly, but the toppings on the pizza were skimpy, and the crust wasn't light & crispy like a thin crust should be. The baked wings with the spicy & sweet rub were bland. They were neither sweet nor spicy, just kinda salty, and the skin was not crispy like I expected but soft and mushy. I should have stuck with the tried and true deep fried wings with buffalo sauce. But Pie Pushers looks like a great place to hang out, up on the second floor up a narrow flight of stairs, overlooking Main Street, and I noticed a sign for a special they had for dine in customers: a pizza and a pitcher of beer for $27. Just make sure to ask for extra of whatever toppings you want.

J

Jennifer Perrucciovia Google

9 months ago

Jennifer with Offline - This is a hidden gem- upstairs! What a great place. Counter order, but great service (especially with a nut allergy) and brought all the food to the table. We got a specialty pizza (Dan’s) and a large house salad- easily fed 3 of us. Delicious food, great service and eclectic atmosphere. Loved it! Will be back.

C

Cj Brownvia Google

9 months ago

It's really good. I got the chicken parm, and it was tasty and sizable, too. The fries were good also. They forgot my Buffalo sauce, but besides that, the service was very good. It not sure how their pizza tastes, but I can at least say the quality of the ingredients is high.