Mellow Mushroom Durham

Cugino Forno Durham brings authentic wood-fired Italian pizza to Durham in a casual, warehouse-style setting. Guests praise crisp, firm crusts and fresh-tasting ingredients, calling the pies among the best they've had. The roomy space offers indoor and outdoor seating with picnic-table dining and a welcoming vibe, plus gelato, desserts, beer, ciders, and a unique make-your-marinara sauce station.

Devil's NY Pizzeria & Restaurant in Durham offers NYC-inspired pizza and a varied menu that includes brunch, vegan/vegetarian options, sandwiches, and lasagna. Guests note a warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly, attentive staff. A standout is a colossal 29-inch pizza made with fresh crust, sauce, and cheese. Generous portions and value-driven pricing keep customers returning.

Located at 402 W Geer St in Durham, Hutchins Garage serves pizza and Italian-inspired fare. Guests praise crispy Brussels sprouts, the Spicy Vodka and Mushroom Pizzas, and affordable drinks. The venue offers outdoor seating (dog-friendly) and GF/vegan options in a casual, welcoming setting. A QR-code ordering system speeds service, though some reviews note it can reduce personal touch; takeout parking is available, otherwise street parking.

Durham's Pizzeria Toro showcases wood-fired pizzas with bold, unique and traditional options, including a vegan cashew-cheese pie. Reviews highlight perfectly baked pies, a seasonal pear dessert, and espresso on the dessert menu. The lively, industrial setting features visible pizza prep and a busy bar; some guests note the space can be loud, but service stays strong during peak hours.

Emmy Squared Pizza: Durham sits in the Brightleaf tobacco warehouses' courtyard at 905 W Main St #25A. Diners praise friendly staff, attentive management, and excellent service, with reservations recommended to minimize waits. The Detroit-style menu includes seasonal pies like Seoul Mate and Arc Angel, gluten-free options, and popular burgers and Brussels sprouts salad, with drinks and desserts earning praise.

Pie Pushers is a Durham pizza restaurant known for New York–style, thin-crust pies like pepperoni and Italian, with welcoming service. Reviews describe an upstairs, eclectic dining area as a hidden gem, feature pizzas such as Dan’s, and generous ingredients. Experiences vary, but many praise the quality pizza, friendly staff, and a lively Main Street atmosphere.