B

Brendenvia Google

about 1 month ago

Definitely fork and knife pizza. Thickest pizza I’ve had in Fort Wayne for sure. They do things a little different though, crust, sauce, toppings, then cheese. So it’s almost like a Chicago deep dish pizza but not as deep dish.

C

Chris Dybenvia Google

about 1 month ago

This has become our favorite pizza place! We like to sit in the cozy bar area cuddled up in a booth. The cocktail list is impressive, they are known for their Long Island Iced Tea, though I settled for a glad of Cabarnet Sovignon., which was delicious. My husband had an IPA which was also tasty. We ordered the house salad, medium size to share. The portion was way more than the two of us could eat. Fresh shredded cheese and the house salad dressing made this dish hard to push away! We had to save room for the deep dish Godfather pizza. We ordered a medium and found again, the size was way more than we needed for just the two of us. Karmen was our server, she was attentive and patient with us as we looked over the menu. The place was so packed by the time we left and with good reason! Best pizza in the Fort!

J

J Santiago Sr.via Google

6 months ago

I really thought this was going to be one of the best in the area. I was a bit disappointed and I brought 2 pies thinking it wasn’t going to be enough. It wasn’t like the NY style I was hoping for. The pizza was good, it had plenty of cheese and it was pretty fat/ thick so I got full fast. The disappointment was that it wasn’t foldable like a thinner crust and it was a bit doughy. My stepson and daughter was like where is the pepperoni 🍕. It was mostly hidden under neath all the cheese, I prefer to be on top like most pizza shops do. So even though it tasted good it was just average pie. Maybe it was because there were just busy or it’s just the way it was made. There is one spot that was wood fired and I wanted to try but there hours close early- there review was average and some ssid it was made sloppy. Who knows, I’m sure they have other great food here but the pizza it be a while before trying again. It’s still a place to check out if in the area.

D

Drew Miniervia Google

6 months ago

The West Jefferson Oley's has so much to offer! Yes, of course they have the best deep dish outside of Chicago, but thats just the tip of the iceberg. All of their dishes are made with an attention to flavor that you just can't find anywhere else. The atmosphere is cozy, and inviting. Maybe you're not looking for a full, delicious Italian meal 🤷 Maybe you would just like a great appetizer and an amazing cocktail, if that's the case, then you'd be a fool to go elsewhere. This place truly is one of a kind in all the best ways!

L

Luke Barnettvia Google

11 months ago

Okay I wasn’t skeptical going in about how great this pizza was. However now I am to a certainty that it is in fact the best pizza I have ever had. Fort Wayne, IN is filled full of great food places as an overall I believe this pizza and this location is one of the best if you are a foodie. The pizza probably weighs 8 lbs for a medium it’s crazy. It’s enough pizza that 3 grown men who were hungry set down to eat 2 mediums and left with a full box of pizza and had trouble walking. If there was 10 stars available I would give it. Every time I come back to Fort Wayne for the rest of my life this will be the spot I eat dinner at least once a week. Staff was great, owner was very chill. They kept my drink full which is great. It’s not just a 1-1 type of thing if another staff member passed by you they will fill your drink as well. Wonderful place to go. 10/10 recommend.