Paloma Wilder

Located at 450 E Mason St in Milwaukee, Kesslers Diamonds is praised for knowledgeable, pressure-free service. Reviews highlight wedding rings, engagement rings, and jewelry repairs, including recreating an heirloom necklace with a color-matched gemstone. The team, including Ryan and the goldsmith Diane, provides friendly, professional guidance and a top-notch customer experience.

Kloiber Jewelers in Milwaukee at 777 E Wisconsin Ave offers engagement rings, custom design, ring sizing, and repairs. Customers praise Emily and Karin for helpful, friendly service, high-quality, made-to-order pieces, and fair pricing. The shop is noted for reliable craftsmanship and a positive experience.

Rohr Jewelers, located at 2622 N Downer Ave in Milwaukee, is a jewelry store known for custom engagement rings and jewelry repairs. Reviews highlight Sam's knowledge and friendly approach, including turning a family diamond into a custom piece and suggesting secure ring settings. The shop is praised for quality workmanship and a welcoming, personalized experience.

Milwaukee's Powers Jewelry Designers at 301 E Wisconsin Ave is a welcoming jewelry store praised for friendly, straightforward service and quality repairs. Customers cite fast turnaround—often under 3 days—affordable options, and staff like Lorry and Tim who remember clients and help find pieces within budget. Services include resizing and polishing; one review notes a communication misstep, highlighting the importance of clear dialogue.

Cival Jewelry Studio offers handmade, small-batch jewelry with ethical sourcing, plus ready-to-wear options and custom design. In-store design sessions—led by Rae and Kathryn—help clients create wedding bands and heirloom pieces in a warm, personal environment. A woman-owned Milwaukee shop grounded in thoughtful service and unique, timeless jewelry.

Edie Boutique, located at 333 N Broadway in Milwaukee, offers a curated mix of shoes, jewelry, and clothing with unique, fashionable pieces. Customer reviews praise stylish selections and friendly staff, while others describe variable service and concerns over returns or exchanges. The store also supports online shoppers with in-store pickup for specific items, making it a versatile fashion destination.