Personalized design and creation of unique engagement rings, including Toi Et Moi and other custom styles.
Expert repairs, resizing, and maintenance for rings, necklaces, and other fine jewelry.
Incorporating family diamonds or gems into new settings to create meaningful, modern pieces.
Selection and customization of wedding bands to complement engagement rings.
Curated collection of ready-made fine jewelry, including rings, necklaces, and accessories.
I needed a necklace repaired and I'm so glad I chose to go here! Sam does quick, quality work for a great price. I will be coming to Rohr for any future jewelry needs.
Had a great experience at Rohr jewelers getting my fiancés ring set! Sam was extremely knowledge and made the experience laid-back. Highly recommend heading to Rohr for all of your jewelry needs!
Had an engagement ring made here by Sam. It was a very unusual custom Toi Et Moi ring. He carefully made it and, when my Fiancé had some issues with it, he took it back and re-did it to iron out the issues. The final product is fantastic. Very pleasant people at Rohr and very happy with the outcome. We will certainly be back for the wedding band. I highly suggest going here for your jewlery needs than any other place. Thank you, Sam, for all you did!
My fiance and I had the BEST experience at Rohr. We were a bit nervous to be shopping for rings as a queer couple, but Sam put us completely at ease. He was funny, knowledgeable and made us feel comfortable. Instead of trying to talk us into the most expensive ring, he convinced me to use the diamond from my great grandma's ring, which made the ring even more meaningful. He offered great suggestions about the setting for the security of the diamond that we wouldn't have considered, and the custom ring turned out even better than imagined. We would highly recommend working with Rohr for your custom engagement ring!
My fiance and I DEEPLY regret getting my brand new engagement ring (purchased elsewhere) sized down through Rohr. The soder point where the shank was cut for resizing the ring broke apart twice in a matter of weeks, the 2nd time it happened was less than 48 hours after I picked it up. While picking up my ring for the 3rd time I noticed my solitare morganite now has an enormous gouge across its face as well as a gouge on the band itself. The clerk who gave it to me insists it's normal wear and tear I just couldn't see before he cleaned it. I have photos of the ring from the day I dropped it off, and this damage was not there. It's my belief that I absolutely would have noticed such significant damage to my brand new engagement ring before leaving it with Rohr. Beware they do NOT document any existing damage when repairing outside jewelry, so sadly they have no paper trail to know either way. We havent even started planning our wedding yet and my fiancé and I now have to save for a whole new engagement ring. UPDATE: 3 weeks later and I've heard nothing from the owner in an attempt to explain himself or rectify this situation - I ultimately had to spend $400 at another locally-owned jeweler who was willing to memorialize this one-and-only 1st engagement ring into a pendant. I'm now out the cost of my original ring, the cost of it's replacement, and $400 to try to salvage this nightmare - and they can't even give me my $50 re-sizing fee back.

Crafting meaningful jewelry with expert care and personalized service in Milwaukee.
No photos available
Rohr Jewelers is a trusted, locally-owned jewelry store in Milwaukee specializing in custom engagement rings, expert repairs, and fine jewelry. Known for our knowledgeable and friendly service, we work closely with clients to create unique, meaningful pieces, including custom designs and heirloom transformations. Our commitment to quality craftsmanship and customer satisfaction makes us a go-to destination for all your jewelry needs, from simple repairs to bespoke creations.
Claim Rohr Jewelers to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.