PT
Pizza Thief
Pizza Thief: Sourdough-inspired pizzas and gourmet flavors for a memorable Portland bite.
4.8
Pizza
$$
Pizza Thief: Sourdough-inspired pizzas and gourmet flavors for a memorable Portland bite.
Pizza Thief at 2610 NW Vaughn St, Portland, OR 97210, offers pizza, sandwiches, desserts, and more in a lively space. Reviewers note a distinctive crust with rye flour and a long fermentation, plus standout items like breakfast pizza, Italian sandwich, cookies, homemade ice cream, and tiramisu. It’s a popular date spot with a welcoming vibe, though some say prices are high and the pizza isn’t the absolute best in town.
No photos available
Gourmet pizzas with a unique rye-flour sourdough crust, available by the slice or whole pie.
Hearty, freshly made sandwiches with dressed lettuce and premium ingredients.
Homemade cookies, tiramisu, ice cream, and other decadent treats.
Fresh salads and sides like jalapeño cheesy bread, with optional dipping sauces.
Quick service for casual dining in a stylish ambiance or convenient takeout orders.
Claim Pizza Thief to update business info, respond to reviews, and access analytics.
Overall rating
Meag
The best pizza in Portland in my opinion. My favorite is the mushroom. I wouldn’t really recommend the sandwich. I don’t know why they don’t toast their bread. Also highly recommend all their cookies!
Jake Prososki
Pizza thief was amazing with great flavor options and such a fun atmosphere. Great location for a date. Lots of yummy slices as well as salads, and desserts. The only reason I wouldn’t give a full 5 stars is the pizza is not the best in town. Based purely on pizza quality - there are a few places in town I’d eat at over pizza thief if I want a good slice.
Hak Williams
A slice above! Even though this is "just pizza", it is not just pizza. This is a place for sourdough lovers and gourmet foodies because if you aren't that you might be slightly annoyed by the interesting crust. This might be the best tasting pizza crust in Portland and that is saying a lot. You can tell there's a little rye flour and that this is a long process dough to make. Probably slightly harder to work with than regular yeasted white flour dough. This is a slice that's worth a moderate drive to try. The look of their sweets had me salivating, and their sandwiches look amazing too. And they've got homemade ice cream and tiramisu in the freezer, oh my! I guess I'll be stopping in regularly.
FATCAT
Yeah, this is def a must-eat pizza place. The breakfast pizza was full of flavor, and the pep was spicy and delish. The Italian sandwich is a must! They even dress the lettuce! If you are a condiment glutton like me, get the ranch. Will be back soon!
Yusuf Ashfaq
Heard many good things about Pizza thief and finally got around to trying it for a casual dinner. It’s definitely located out of the way on the industrial side of Portland compared to other places. The interior and ambience is definitely nice. It’s connected to a bar which is behind a wall which is convenient for those who do not want to be around alcohol. Service was very quick and you order at the front. The pizza itself was unfortunately not the best in my opinion. I’ve heard so many great things but it felt like a lower quality bar style more greasy pizza. I didn’t feel that quality that I have from other pizza places around Portland. The jalapeño cheesy bread was solid and they definitely added a ton of jalapeños. Pricing felt slightly on the higher side and they charge for sides and dipping sauces. Portion size was solid. Overall, definitely worth a try but I’m not sure if I’d personally seek this place out given the number of other great options around Portland!
